Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Has Science Disproved God?

Have I told you about this? Anyway, debate at Oxford Uni:

Has Science Disproved God?
Richard Dawkins on the 'God Delusion'
Reverend Professor Alister McGrath [Professor of Theology, Oxford University]
Tuesday, 27th February 2007 @ 8:15pm

13 Comments:

Blogger Metro said...

I always liked Douglas Adams' contention that proof makes faith impossible. Faith is a belief in that which cannot be proven.

I'm reading an interesting book by Lois McMaster Bujold. I don't go in for fantasy much, but I really enjoy her writing.

In the book, the world is ruled by five gods, and they are as matter-of-fact and real as the fingers of a hand.

There are no atheists. There is no hell as we conceive it, just a place of formlessness and noisy void, presided over by the fifth god. People take the gods in stride and the biggest "heresy" is over whether the fifth god is a god or a devil.

If science ever gives us proof of any god, will it lead to great religious war (probably), to new mutual understandings (faint hope) or to a new atheism wherein what we thought was god is just another being, albeit a powerful one?

Until then, I feel we must accept that a god or gods are unproven, but real to some.

And also that a belief in the absurdly unprovable has never stopped humans from making social policy out of it.

I view religion as a superstition akin to psychic phenomena and cold fusion. It may exist, but no-one has ever reliably demonstrated so in controlled conditions.

Only the weight of history makes me give Christianity or Islam more "thought space" than scientology or crystal healing. That and a personal prejudice bred of growing up in a faith-driven household.

Thursday, February 15, 2007 11:27:00 AM  
Blogger Philipa said...

A quite brilliant comment that leaves me speechless but nodding in agreement.

Thursday, February 15, 2007 2:08:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have to say I disagree...

To me faith is useless without proof, or at the very least evidence. If you have no evidence, why not believe anything whatsoever? With no evidence Christianity is just as valid as the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

Those who claim that there is and can be no evidence for religion are just too lazy to look. Jews (those that believe in God anyway) usually believe that if one keeps the law, one is blessed in the world. Islam believes that the Qu'ran is infallible and inerrant in every place and sense. New agers believe a variety of things, but they often include such things are crystal healing and dousing. And Christianity believes that the Son of God was incarnate (at a certain point in time and space), lived to conduct a 3-year rabble-rousing ministry before being executed and triggering the Christian faith. All of these are testable claims! You can test crystal healing in a lab, you can test the jewish claim statistically, you can assess the Qu'ran however you like to see if it stands up. You can test whether Christ existed by contemporary sources, Christians normally cite Josephus, and if he did you can apply C.S.Lewis' trilemma to determine if you believe he was a lunatic, liar or Lord.

All these tests will produce results, some of which will help and some of which will hinder the religious apologist's case. For example, I actually suspect that statistically Jews have been 'rewarded' more than non-Jews (when talking about wealth anyway, and depending on how you value the holocaust!). Of course there are many other explanations for it, Britons have also been 'rewarded' more than Rwandans. At this point it is for people to use common sense and reason to determine how many if any of the religious theologies so far concocted has any value. Common sense and reason lead me to believe that most (though not all) of the central claims of Christianity are true. As such I am a Christian. But I have to say it annoys me substantially when people claim that religion can have no rational basis, evidence or proof, because it implies that I am foolish. I come from an atheistic scientific background, and came to religion the science and reason, and resent the implication that I was converted by some nut-job preacher or moment of psychological failing grasping for crutches (I'm not suggesting that that implication comes from you metro!)

I will be going to this talk for certain.

Friday, February 16, 2007 2:16:00 AM  
Blogger Metro said...

Interesting point Jack.

Are Iraqi Shiites happier than Sunnis? What about Norwegians?

Believers in America apparently often self-identify as happier on surveys, but how are we to measure that empirically?

If Christians believe that poverty is virtuous and we find that most Christians are rich (as I suspect, by world standards may be the case) then have they been blessed or are they cursed?

If I did the right math, could I prove to you that Scientologists (many of whom are highly successful multi-millionaires) are actually following the One True Faith?

And while we're on the topic, on what basis do you think Jews have been better-"rewarded" than non-Jews?

Would we find that families are rewarded according to their devotion and devoutness? And how would we measure that?

If the Holocaust is apparently subject to interpretation as blessing, does that mean that homosexuals and Poles are blessed too? Five million Poles died in that same inferno, and thousands of gays.

I respectfully submit that the existence of God is firmly unprovable by any scientifically acceptable standard.

You can't put salt on god's tail. You can't see him, hear him, taste, touch, or smell him. All anyone can do is point at something and say "that's proof to me (and only me) that god exists."

To say so requires pure and unprovable faith. And that's cool by me.

Friday, February 16, 2007 12:23:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm afraid I think you've missed my point metro. (Sorry for the delayed reply)

I wasn't saying that religions whose members are rich/virtuous/happy are necessarily correct, I was saying that almost all religions make claims which can be tested empirically. On such claim is the old Jewish one that God blesses those who keep the law (testing this would only be testing judaism). The other claims are in fact more verifiable - the most (un)verifiable of all are the new-age ones.

New Agers claim a variety of things, varying even among themselves. However it's easy to assess many of them. Some examples:
- Crystal healing is not only scientifically unexplained, it also has no experimental evidence.
- Dousing when done in a double-blind controlled study produces no result.
- I have had Tarot readings done which never came true.
- My dad has read astrological personality profiles for me and my brother, and could not identify which was which! He believes in astrology so had an obvious incentive to try and guess.

The last two of those are non-scientific and specific to me, but they are still evidence which is based on empirical data and not blind faith. For these four reasons among others I don't believe in most New Age ideas.

Islam makes a number of claims, but the easiest to test is that the Qu'ran is perfect and utterly true. This is a belief held by almost all muslims. However:
- There are not just bits which I thoroughly disapprove of in the Qu'ran (weakening subjectively my own belief in it's perfection), but many contradictions, which create logically impossible statements if both are true (weakening scientifically the claim).

For this reason, among others, I am not a muslim.

Evangelical Christians claim that the Bible is the infallible word of God. However:
- As above, the Bible has bits I cannot agree with, and is riddled with contradictions.
- The 'Bible' is not an actual entity, with many books in dispute by many different Christians sects, weakening it's reliability.

For these reasons, among others, I am not an evangelical Christian.

The list goes on for Catholics and everyone else, leaving me in the Liberal Christian camp. But my point is, each 'faith' makes testable claims, some of the most testable can even be tested in a lab. Thus, religions are in many ways just like any scientific theories - making falsifiable claims.

As for "You can't put salt on god's tail. You can't see him, ..." you know that's irrelevant. Do you see/hear/feel/taste or smell Neutrinos? How about protons and neutrons? For that matter atoms? molecules? gravity? magnetism? the ether? All these are theoretical. There is evidence for (or against) each, but no conclusive proof of any, and no personal experience of any either. And if you're about to say they can be inferred from evidence, well that's true but so can religious claims. A lot of religious people infer God's existence from the world's. There are alternative explanations, but then there are alternative explanations to atoms too.

As C S Lewis said: "I believe in Christianity as I believe that the Sun has risen, not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else." The same can be said of most ideas in physics - including the ones above.

Wednesday, March 07, 2007 2:14:00 PM  
Blogger Metro said...

@ Jack

We don't entirely disagree. I also feel that the Bible also contains a number of contradictions, particularly if taken literally. Among the greatest is the claim to monotheism of a religion that worships a trinity, but I digress.

The question is what provable claims Christianity makes. Unfortunately, if you're not going to a version of the Bible for them, you're kind of stuck for sources for those claims, no?

But let's say such claims can be found that originate outside the Bible: What test will satisfy the skeptic as to the reality of a god?

We have photographic images of atoms. We can prove mathematically and otherwise with near-certainty the existence of smaller particles.

Science takes on falsifiable claims and tries to parse them for a verifiable, unfalsifiable result. Science cannot exist without proof. Hypothesis to "theory" and on to law. ("Theory" in science meaning a great deal more than just an educated guess.)

You're incorrect in saying that being unable to prove the existence of a god is irrelevant. In fact it is the heart of the matter: The point of faith is that faith cannot co-exist with proof. Nor can true faith co-exist with utter and complete certainty. A faith unquestioned and unquestioning cannot be valid against the world.

To simply point to the world and say "Look--god made that" is to invite the question "Can you prove that, and if so, how?"

It's worse than simply post hoc, propter hoc because the premise is actually that God exists because the world exists (which is backward reasoning).

But since we have not proven the existence of a god in the first place, the actual thesis is "The thing whose existence is uncertain created something whose creation is attributed scientifically to something else, therefore its existence is certain."

I might just as well infer the existence of Jack Frost from a jar of strawberry jam.

As with everything else, science is attempting, with some sucess, to unravel the answers. Religion is fighting against science to deny its claims, but making no proveable discoveries to advance its own ideas.

Where are the great scientific discoveries that prove a god? In what reputable journals were the researches published, and how have these claims been tested?

Ah--but of course the great discoveries have been made: "As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be ..." No need for further investigation--we can just fight off science by simple denial.

Or when science drops an atom on our doorstep we can say "Well our god made THAT, too."

Lewis was right. Faith in a god colours the way a person views everything. Atheists have to look at the world without this distortion.

Friday, March 09, 2007 11:19:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Metro, I'm not here trying to convert you to being a theist or a member of any religion, I'm simply disputing the idea that faith can have no rational basis.

I don't deny that religions aren't proven, or in fact even hinted at scientifically. The only scientific proof which points to religion is Godel's Incompleteness Theorem, and that provides no notion of which if any religion may be correct. I could be making this same argument with no changes to the argument as an atheist, my case is that religious beliefs are not by necessity unfalsifiable.

Some may be unfalsifiable if they make no testable predictions, however as I've tried to show many do do so. I'm not here making any statements about truth, except to say that it is UNtrue that all faith is necessarily irrational. You made the opposite assertion yourself: "The point of faith is that faith cannot co-exist with proof" which I completely disagree with, neither do I see why you have said it. You make a leap which is logicall flawed, going from demonstrating (in my view correctly) that science shows no evidence for God to saying that it's impossible for evidence to be found. There is no logical link there I'm afraid, it's a fallacy, you're saying: "All A are B. Therefore all B are A." But this is wrong - and millenia of mathematicians and logicians will back me up.

Likewise millenia of science backs me up when I say it regularly works backwards. The classic (false) story of Newton and the apple is a good example - Newton observed something and had an idea about how it might have happened. He then took the step which many people of faith fail to take (but which I say is possible) - to test his theory to see if it predicted things which are true. Likewise with evolution, Darwin observed the state of animals and observed the similarities and differences; he then inferred a possible theory and tested its predictions. Theists do the same, they observe the world, and come up with a theory about how it happened - what they usually fail to do is to test that theory.

In his book entitled "The God Delusion" Richard Dawkins actually agrees with me. He thinks as I do that religions can be treated scientifically, and formulates "the God Hypothesis". His assessment comes out with a different result to mine though.

But I'm curious since you're the one making the exclusive statement (and so the burden of proof rests on you), for what reason do you think that faith is inherently unfalsifiable?

Friday, March 09, 2007 12:47:00 PM  
Blogger Metro said...

Okey-doke.

Sorry, I was having the devil's own time signing in. Almost makes one wonder ...

So we agree that there is no scientific evidence of the existence of a god.

Therefore the only evidence upon which to base one's belief in a god is the account of someone else's alleged personal experience of a god, or in some cases the belief that we have directly experienced God--without evidence that anyone else will absolutely accept as proof (unless they are already believers).

Faith therefore is belief without evidence. And must remain so. If evidence is ever found, it would be as unneccesary to have faith in God as it would to have faith in gravity, wouldn't it?

God would become humdrum and wholly unremarkable, a nine-day wonder and done on the tenth. We'd try to follow His laws, but that would become routine and rote. Belief there might be, but not faith. Hence faith and proof cannot co-exist without rewriting the definition of the word.

We cannot actually experience the faith of others. The truly faithful must plod on with nothing but the "evidence" of their hearts to sustain them. There is no test to separate the faithful believer from the charlatan or fake.

So faith is really an entirely untestable, internal phenomenon. Each of us in our lonely skulls carries what we think of as god and pray to--or not, as the case may be. If it is a true faith, it is untestable and unfalsifiable. If it's not a true faith, then only the person faking it could know, provided he rubbed blue mud in his navel when required by ritual.

So I don't think it's unfalsifiable as you term it, from the outside it's quite possible to fake it. Yet only the person of faith can know the depth and strength of that faith. And even the truest of believers sometimes are quite deluded.

I'm intrigued by your statement that there are testable claims for faith in a god; What do you have in mind? After all, if faith could move mountains, one would expect geography classes to be much more exciting than they are.

It is just possible that evidence for the existence of a god might one day be found. But in at least two millenia of trying, the last century with quite sophisticated instruments not only scientific but rhetorical and philosophical, not one iota of confirmable, verifiable, scientifically acceptable proof has been found yet. And unlike any hypothetical gods, I don't have eternity to wait until there is.

So why should the gods of this century be awarded any more respect than the cultural prejudices of ancient empires and the dead gods of other pantheons? If Jupiter, Samhain, Bilquis and Thor are all false and rightly have been consigned to darkness and the halls of mythology, then why are Yaweh, Allah, and Krishna handed more respect? What makes them any "truer" than the thousands of gods that went before?

And it dosen't work backwards. A watch in a field is proof of the existence of a watchmaker, not a god. The existence of the world proves only that the world exists. Not that anyone created it.

Thursday, March 15, 2007 2:16:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"A watch in a field is proof of the existence of a watchmaker..."

A world in a universe is proof of the existence of a worldmaker (or so the parallel argument goes).

That little aside aside, I think the crux of this problem comes down to differing definitions of faith. I'll move on to that in a second though, after mentioning one other thing:
You claim: "So we agree that there is no scientific evidence of the existence of a god... Therefore the only evidence upon which to base one's belief in a god is the account of someone else's alleged personal experience of a god..."

No, I appeal to a third form of rational evidence other than science and witness: logic. Mathematical theories are not proven scientifically, they are deduced logically. I believe the same can be done for at least one religion (Christianity in some form).

Back to the definition of faith, I do study Theology, at an admittedly low-level being an undergraduate; however I would suggest that if a more expert definition is needed then it is not going to be helpful as a common word! The definition in the Compact OED is:
"faith
• noun
1 complete trust or confidence.
2 strong belief in a religion.
3 a system of religious belief."
Although I would wonder about the first meaning being compatible with continued scientific exploration, the second and third are entirely consistent (the definition of religion includes nothing about 'blind' faith either, or lack of evidence).

I agree that blind faith is incompatible with scientific evidence, but I deny the same about true faith. I also think that the way Jesus teaches about faith does not necessitate blind faith, although it can encompass it. Jesus may not be considered a God by two-thirds of the world's population, but it would be hard not to count him as a prominent religious teacher.

You asked again about the examples of falsifiable statements by religions, and I refer you back to my prior postings where I have mentioned many, particularly crystal worship, prayer, and the perfectness of the Qu'ran.

Friday, March 16, 2007 5:03:00 AM  
Blogger Metro said...

Ah, but the watchmaker argument is a fallacy. It takes an object that we know to be an artifact and then makes the illogical leap that the world must also be an artefact, which in fact presumes the existence of an artificer. A better analogy would be finding a small smooth stone in a field. But that doesn't address the argument.

I feel we're sometimes arguing very similar points from different directions here. I utterly agree with you that faith must not be blind.

It must be tested. It may be tested internally--the "dark night of the soul"--or externally, for example by martyrdom.

But the truth of faith can only ever reside in the mind of the person experiencing it. No matter how that person may witness or proclaim their faith. Even martyrs might die for reasons other than their faith.

A system of religious belief dangles from a single stalk: the complete trust and confidence in the existence of God. Therefore all definitions are appropriate here.

Thus I tend to see the word in its first sense. Untestable, faith in God lies in our hearts and our minds, and only we can look there and tell if we have a robust faith that survives testing, or a shell of faith, constructed of ritual or habits of thought, but neither strong enough to support us nor connected enough to truly influence us.

Logic can be used to prove many things, but remember that logic predicted the H-bomb couldn't work at one time.

If your first principle is "Look--here is this marvellous and complex world we live in, don't you think someone had to be behind it?" then I tend to feel that you're starting from the wrong foot. Forgive me for choosing a simplistic example. I'm not sure where you'd start from to logically prove the existence of God.

As far as testability goes, I think that if you asked a Muslim about the perfection of the Koran you might get the same sentiments as you would from a Baptist asked about the perfection of the Bible. And could either be right?

I'm very interested in the logical argument for the existence of a god--particularly as this has led you to a Christian God. Is there a link you like for this?

Friday, March 16, 2007 11:32:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Unfortunately not a link, but a book: "Mere Christianity" by C.S. Lewis. I will give an example of one of his lines of reasoning in a moment, and you are indeed right in giving me the benefit of the doubt on creation - I did not and do not see the world and assume a God, but others do which is why I mention it.

I still think it is valid as an example of the first step of scientific exploration though. Scientists do regularly work backwards, I mentioned Isaac Newton and Darwin, there are of course more, however I would actually say that it is by far the most common basis for scientific exploration. Observing something and suggesting a cause, this is what happens with the watchmaker example and with the creationist. However, this is all fairly pointless since regardless of whether we agree on this point, we do agree that theists rarely take the next step and examine their hypothesis of a creator scientifically. Neither do I, since a creator is not important to me and I did not reach theism by this route.

I also disagree that a system of religious belief "dangles from a single stalk" because not all religions are theistic. Indeed if you, as I do, accept political theory and various forms of atheism as religions, then I could argue that most religions are non-theistic. For those that do include a god, a "God" may not be vital, most notably in modern Judaism and the old Pagan religions of western europe. Hence not all religion dangles from that stalk, and so I do not believe that that stalk alone is the one which needs to be addressed. It's survival will of course be key to almost any Christian or Muslim however.

For testability of the Bible and Qu'ran, yes I agree, an Evangelical and a Muslim would each argue the case for their own book's perfection. However you then seem to arrive at the conclusion that this would end in an impasse. This is not necessarily true, and I believe that I could at the very least shed doubt on either, if not disprove the perfect nature of both. I believe I certainly can with the Bible, and I regularly argue with evangelicals in an attempt to do so.

With those, largely irrelevant, aspects aside, I'd like to answer your final question about the logical argument for the existence of a god. However, before doing so I'd like to make one thing clear: I'm not trying to convert you, and am not especially interested in arguing it to its conclusion. In any case I am worse at expressing it and less comprehensive than C.S. Lewis, and so I would once again recommend his book. As such I'll be more than happy to discuss it and answer questions about what I think about the logic, but I'm not looking for us to examine each and every aspect in minute detail, nor to have a long-running debate about the voracity of the particular case. It's just an example to answer your question:

It's called the Trilemma, and like all logical arguments is based on a few basic assumptions. These can be justified, but won't be here because of the scope; suffice it to say that this logic aims to show that Jesus is the Son of God, and to do so requires us to assume that his actions and claims in the Gospels have been accurately recounted.

Jesus claimed that he was God's Son. Therefore we have two options: either he was or he wasn't. If he was then the argument is over, if he was not then we have two further options: either he knew he was not (a Liar) or he did not know that he was not (Lunatic). The summary words are chosen primarily to fit into a nice alliteration of "Liar, Lunatic or Lord?", however as C.S. Lewis points out, the titles are, if anything, not extreme enough. The definition of a 'god', and particularly of the Jewish "God", were very well-defined at the time and to call oneself the Son of God while not being one is akin to calling oneself the Son of a Poached Egg - lunacy. In a similar vein, purporting yourself to be the Son of God, and requiring those who follow you to put their eternal souls into your care is deception on a diabolical level. C.S. Lewis does not perceive Jesus as Diabolical nor as a Lunatic (again he justifies this) and thus concludes that he must have been the Son of God.

I hope that summary is sufficient to convey most of the meaning to you. He of course addresses the validity od the Bible, the lunatic and liar cases, and so on in greater depth. Incidentally his most vehement claim is that Jesus CANNOT be thought of as "just a good moral teacher".

Saturday, March 17, 2007 5:02:00 AM  
Blogger Metro said...

Thanks very much. I have "Mere Christianity" around. My sister gave it to me. I'm about ready for a new book to read, so perhaps I'll start there.

I'll grant you the watchmaker example presents a case for scientific inquiry. But the found object, if that's the argument, could be anything at all.

Political theory seems to me to depend from religious motives, but exists as a seperate entity. Many countries whose founders were Christian types specify the separation of church and state, and it's an increasing trend. I say this in full recognition that our head of state is also the chief of a church.

Atheism is a perfect example of faith needing a lack of proof. If ever it is proven that there is no god, there will be no need to claim to adhere to a philosophy called atheism.

To maintain an atheist attitude requires a need and willingness to speak out against a world of theisms and say "I do NOT believe". Was there ever a sillier statement made more necessary?

Modern Judaism without god? I can't even picture it. With the exception of Buddhism, animist practices perhaps, and some of the neo-pagan pretensions (which I regard as fashion and not a religion), I think religions have, indeed require, gods. I'd be interested in counter-examples.

You're definitely right, though, that this discussion has gone on far too long for a comment thread. But thanks for taking the time. It's arguments like these that make me hopeful and thoughtful.

I'll try to read Lewis, and perhaps we can discuss it sometime. I'm at tedmorris002002 AT yahoo DOT co DOT uk.

Good luck in your theological studies; and see you around.

Saturday, March 17, 2007 11:37:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"I'd be interested in counter-examples."

Since I'm interested too, I thought I'd mention them. You correctly observed Buddhism, and so I'll leave that out. It does of course entail belief in the supernatural, and I could accept a definition of religion which necessitated that, although it would not fit with my current one.

Judaism is the most interesting I think. You say that you can't picture it without a god, but luckily you don't have to imagine it, you can observe it. 'Judaism' has always been a tribe, and for most non-liberal jews it still is, simply a label for a bloodline. I know a lot of jews who are atheists, but still call themselves jews and get offended if you suggest that they're not. The reason is that for them judaism is a "way of life" rather than a set of beliefs, and is largely just adherence to the practices of their parents and ancestors, which helps to define them personally and culturally. Almost all Jews agree that the only requirement to be a Jew is to have a Jewish mother - there are no doctrinal requirements.

There is also a theological reason though. The vast majority of Jews do not believe there are any prophets now, or indeed since about 600 BC. Neither, you will observe, are there any priests. Judaism had priests, until 70 AD when the Romans destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem. The Temple (where God resided), the priests, and the prophets were Judaism's links with God, the centres of their religion; the only other central aspect being the Torah, the book of law traditionally handed down from Moses.

Since the prophets ceased to come, the Temple was destroyed and the priests abolished, Judaism has only had one pillar left, the Torah, with their teachers (Rabbis) to discuss its meaning and teach its message. But Rabbis were/are teachers not priests, with no link to God, and the Torah is just a record of what Moses reputedly wrote. As such Judaism changed into "Rabbinic Judaism", losing its links to God and becoming simply a set of passed down teachings and traditions. With the loss of its links, Judaism in effect lost its God, and although some Jews may be theists, even Jewish theists, it is not necessary to make a Jew, and 'God' actually has no role in the religion of most of them. Whether he exists or not, it's not possible to make contact with him and so he is irrelevant.

As for other counter-examples, as you mentioned with animism and neo-pagans there are those religions who believe in the supernatural, but either do not use the label 'god' or think of their Gods more in terms of non-sentient powers or human archetypes. There is a strong history of this too, although it could never be said to have entered into the mainstream.

If you decide to read Mere Christianity then do let me know what you think, I'll get you my e-mail address too.

All the Best,

Jack

Monday, March 19, 2007 8:35:00 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home